Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

I have been known to go a little overboard decorating cookies and cakes for special occasions. I see a photo or get an idea in my head and think, “That would be fun. I can do that.”  Hours and hours later it becomes apparent that many things in life  look easy until you actually try them. Artistically decorating cookies with royal icing isn’t easy. Luckily this faux version is.

If you are an experienced cookie decorator, you know a lot more than me. I am a complete beginner. But iced sugar cookies are a great care package cookie.They taste wonderful and last a really long time (2-3 weeks).  I am not suggesting that these are the sort of thing you might whip up an hour or so before heading to the post office. Nor am I suggesting that these would be great to make on a weekly basis. However, they ARE really special and would be great for a special occasion care package like a birthday or holiday. I am going to share an easy cookie and an easy faux royal icing recipe (thanks to Though the results are slightly different than using real royal icing, they are still pretty impressive for a cookie decorating rookie.

One of the amazing things about food bloggers, is their generosity of spirit. You might think that some of these talented people would want to keep their methods, recipes, and designs top secret. But they don’t. They share. Three of my favorite cookie decorating sites are,, and You have to take a look at their cookies. After ooo-ing and ahhh-ing at the beautiful designs, you can read directions and tutorials to make the cookies yourself. Assuming, of course, that you are as talented as the three women on these sites. Otherwise, you can oooo and ahhhh, then, like me, make a feeble attempt at creating something similar.

I had spent enough time ogling cookie decorating sites to get the idea that I was capable of trying it out. My first opportunity came in the form of a soon to be five year old who, for many months before his birthday, carried his stuffed Super Mario Yoshi, every where he went. This sweet Yoshi obsessed child is the son of my English student. They have a large extended family that gathers for special occasions like birthdays. I got the brilliant idea that I could be helpful by making a birthday present tray of Yoshi cookies for their celebration.

I went online and found a photo of Yoshi cookies by SweetSugarBell. Not having any of the cookie cutters “just” meant cutting them all out by hand. I watched tutorials online about outlining the shapes then flooding the shapes with thinned icing. Having a few icing tips seemed like a good idea so I purchased three tips. Day 1: I baked. Day two: I outlined in the morning and flooded in the afternoon. (And when I say “day”, I mean many hours of that day.) Day 3: I presented my cookies to the birthday boy. Unfortunately, some time in the past three days he had “outgrown” Yoshi and was now carrying around a stuffed tiger. Oh well.

Though it was a long process, I had a lot of fun. I also had a big reality check, as in, “Whoa, this is a lot harder and more time consuming than I expected!”

The iced sugar cookie leaves(pictured at the top of this post) are a WHOLE lot easier. (Thanks to for the inspiration.) First of all, I used a cookie cutter. If you are planning on mailing cut-out cookies, choose shapes that are as rounded and compact as possible (a round ornament as opposed to a reindeer or a star as opposed to a menorah, for example). Legs, antlers, ears, are the first to go if the cookies jiggle at all in the mail. Second of all, there is no detail work in this icing. It was all rather free form tie-dye look.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

This cookie recipe produces dough that is very easy to work with. Make sure to roll it out to no more than 1/8” to ¼”. It does puff up a bit in the oven and the finished cookie is on the soft side. I especially like that this cookie is barely sweet. The icing provides plenty of sweetness. I used vanilla extract in both my cookies and my icing. I think lemon or almond would work equally well.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

The icing couldn’t be easier. For these leaves the consistency should pour off a spoon thickly, kind of like honey. Any thinner, and it will drip off the edge of your cookie (which isn’t a disaster but is messy). Any thicker, and it won’t blend together on the cookie and will just lie there in piped stripes (also not a disaster but not the look we are going for). No special equipment is required for this style of decorating. Piping tips give you a little more control but the icing can easily be piped out of  a plastic bag with a tiny bit cut off of a bottom corner.

I learned an odd lesson at the cake/candy decorating store when I asked about icing color. Whenever I have tried to make an intense color of frosting or icing, I have battled with color vs bitterness. When I add enough coloring to make a real red or a real black, the icing tastes terrible. I was sure it was something I was doing wrong or maybe I wasn’t using the right product. So I asked. Basically, the answer was that beautiful colors are for looking at not eating. Add enough chemicals to create dark color and you will taste them. Yuck. It helps if the base color isn’t white. Add cocoa to icing you plan to color black or brown. Add cherry juice to icing that you want to make red. Also I learned that there is something called “no taste” red (or tulip red) that doesn’t have a fire engine red color but also doesn’t taste bitter. Most oddly, it appears that not everyone tastes the bitterness of added color. I taste it. Using intense colors for detail work only, seems to be the best bet to me.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

To create the marbling effect on these leaves, I started by piping two  outlining rows of each color, beginning at the outside edge.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday BoxDecorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday BoxDecorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

When the cookie surface is filled in with icing, drag the tip of a toothpick from the inside to the outside edge. Lift. Wipe off the tip and drag in another spot.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday BoxDecorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday BoxDecorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

Allow the cookies to dry overnight, uncovered, at room temperature. Do not store in the refrigerator because it does weird things to the icing. When the icing is hard (in 12-24 hours) store in plastic wrap or airtight containers for 2-3 weeks.

Decorated Thanksgiving Sugar Cookies | The Monday Box

Cut-out Sugar Cookies


(Printable recipe)

Makes about 3 dozen 3” cookies

5 cups all-purpose flour

2 teaspoons baking powder

2 teaspoons salt

1 ½ cups butter, softened

2 cups sugar

4 large eggs

2 teaspoons vanilla extract

  • In a medium bowl, whisk together flour, baking powder, and salt.
  • In the bowl of an electric mixer, cream together the butter and sugar. Add the eggs, one at a time. Add the vanilla. Beat until fluffy (about 3 minutes).
  • Add in the flour mixture, a little at a time, and beat until combined.
  • Cover in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 2 hours.
  • When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 400 degrees F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
  • Roll out the dough on a floured surface or between two sheets of parchment paper to 1/8”-1/4” thickness. Cut into shapes.
  • Place cut-out cookies on prepared cookie sheet 2” apart.
  • Bake for 8-10 minutes until edges are golden brown.
  • Cool completely on wire racks before decorating.
  • Cookies can be wrapped and frozen to be iced at a later time. Be sure to defrost completely before icing.

Faux Royal Icing


4 cups confectioners’ sugar

3 Tablespoons milk (add more as needed to achieve desired consistency)

3 Tablespoons light corn syrup

1 teaspoon vanilla

food coloring

  • Combine sugar and milk until smooth.
  • Add corn syrup and vanilla. Continue beating together until smooth and glossy. Add additional milk in tablespoon increments until desired consistency.
  • Divide into small bowls. Add food coloring and mix.
  • Spoon icing into piping bags or small plastic bag with bottom corner cut to form tiny piping opening.

Packing tips: Wrap pairs of cookies back to back in plastic wrap. Then place inside large zip lock bag or air tight container. For shipping, make sure the cookies fit snuggly in their container with no wiggle room. These cookies will remain fresh wrapped and stored at room temperature for 2-3 weeks.


  1. laurel says

    Hi Wendy,
    As usual I love viewing your site. The cookie leaves look scrumptious. I also enjoyed reading about the process you go through to arrive at your perfect creations. I’ve told all my friends about the Monday box. Is there anything else I can do to help promote your site?
    I hope you had a very Happy Thanksgiving ! I’m looking forward to next week’s installment. Are you making something special for Chanukah ?

    • says

      Thanks, Laurel! I hope you and the kidlets had a happy Thanksgiving! This sugar cookie is soft, almost cake-like, and it really is scrumptious. Thanks also for letting people know about The Monday Box. I am having fun creating (the cookies and the blog), so I just have to hope that along with the fun, “If I build it, they will come!” I haven’t figured out my Chanukah post yet. I better get moving. Chanunakah is around the corner! Just in case, these sugar cookies would make great dreidles and stars. :) Wendy

    • says

      Thanks, Dini! These are super easy to do, though I think they look quite impressive. I made them with children and we had a great time! There is no right or wrong with these, so it is impossible to mess up! :) Have fun. :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *